Monday, September 10, 2012

Week 1

Well, Browns regular season football is back.  Like the Chinese proverb, I'm not sure if that's good news or bad news.

We need some perspective though.  Who honestly thought that the Browns were going to beat the Eagles?  While they certainly could should have, they did as we all expected them to do.  Their record is no different than most predicted coming out of week 1.  The reasons for that are many.  The Browns started a rookie quarterback, a rookie running back, a rookie right tackle, and had two rookie receivers on the field much of the day, against an Eagles defense that has some serious talent.  The struggles were expected, albeit incredibly frustrating.  And there will be more struggles this season, rest assured.  It's the nature of the beast with the way this team is constructed.  There were positives.  The defense played outstanding.  Phil Dawson was his usual self.  The special teams looked pretty solid.  But yes, undeniably, those positives were overshadowed by the negatives, especially on the offensive side of the ball. 

Let's start with the bad.  This is how Brandon Weeden's day started.


It actually got worse from there.  He looked like a rookie quarterback making his first start.  He overthrew Massaquoi on a sure touchdown early in the game.  That one I chalked up to adrenaline.  He was high on many throws early, and had guys in his face most of the game (more on that in a bit).  The corner route to Alex Smith late in the game was a terrible pass, he missed a wide open Smith by 5 yards.  He drops that one in and the Browns probably win.  Whether it was his first read to throw to the 5'8 Travis Benjamin on go routes against 6'2 Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie I can't say, but after the first one I might have avoided that matchup.  And the final interception was an abysmal pass that was at least 5 yards high and behind Massaquoi.  His accuracy was Derek Anderson-esque, which hurts me to even type. 

He certainly wasn't helped out by his supporting cast, namely Greg FREAKING Little, who caused Weeden's first pick with an absolutely unforgivable drop on a bullet that hit him in the hands/face at the 3 yard line and bounced into Kurt Coleman's hands.  If he catches that one it's a different ballgame, at the very least the Browns get 3 there if he hangs on.  At the end of the half, on a 3rd and 1, with the Browns seemingly content to run out the clock, Weeden put on directly into the hands of Owen Marecic, who predictably dropped the ball.  John Lynch who was announcing for FOX said they ran the that same play in practice, and that Marecic dropped that one.  He was stunned that they ran the play in the game (obviously his first Pat Shurmur experience).  I was happy when the drafted Marecic, but I've honestly never seen him block well or catch 1 damn pass.  He's as worthless a fullback as has ever existed in the NFL.  I would have cut him at halftime if I was the GM.  I read on a Browns forum that last season he made a total of 2 good blocks and sustained concussions on both.  He didn't have to worry about that on Sunday, because he did nothing.  Anyway, Browns punt, Eagles get the ball back, and score.  Different ballgame.  The margin for error is going to be so small with this team that those mistakes are going to be the difference, and in this game they were.

Weeden was bad, but Mitchell Schwartz was horrible.  Jason Babin owned him the entire game.  He was abused on every play I focused on him,  Babin is a good player, don't get me wrong, but he flat out dominated Schwartz the entire game.  It was ugly.  He was a big part of the problem with the offense on Sunday, they couldn't run his way and he couldn't block one on one in the passing game.  Hard to be a successful offense with a defensive end in the backfield the entire game. 

Trent Richardson looked like a rookie running back, although he didn't have too much room to operate.  He dropped a screen pass and ran into the pile a few carries, but hard to find too much fault with him.  He's going to be special.  At least there was this.



Again, there were some bright spots.  The defense played an outstanding game.  D'Qwell Jackson is an absolute stud.  Every player on the defensive line looked good to me.  Both Craig Robertson and LJ Fort stepped in to a tough situation and made plays.  If Fort could've made one more though.....

Joe Haden is a stud and it is really going to hurt when he gets suspended, and TJ Ward played well.  It's really hard to find fault with a defense that can hold that explosive of an offense to 17 points.  They were outstanding and fun to watch.

Josh Cribbs had some nice returns and Phil Dawson is awesome.

It was one game, the first for many key players that will hopefully be a part of this franchise's turnaround.  I think they will all get better.  I expect Schwartz and Weeden to improve a ton, starting this week against Cincinnati, and continuing throughout the season.  I think Richardson is a beast.  If Haden plays I actually think they beat the Bengals next Sunday, though that may be getting ahead of myself.

I'm not going to get into all the reasons here, because there will be plenty of time for second guessing this season, but Pat Shurmur is the worst head coach in the NFL.  GO FOR 2 DUMMY.  And mix up your stale, predictable playcalling.  He's terrible. 

There is hope for the future, and even though this one hurt, they're going to be better.  And there's this.

2 comments:

  1. Eric, I got to see whatever slice of the game you can see on Red Zone and bootleg internet feeds. Assuming Richardson stays healthy there has to be improvement (and I'm a half full guy.....) but there's a few fears I have.

    1. When I look at the WR's I still see last year's numero uno - Massaquoi - on the top of the depth chart. Now, I'm not casting aspersions or anything, but hey. How often does he draw double coverage? Where is the upgrade in the passing game?

    2. I know he's new but a 5.1 QB rating? That's disturbing. Worse case scenario is the Browns discover that while Weeden was masterful at Okie Lite, it was partly because teams rarely got pressure on him, and he was tossing bubble screens and easy throws.

    It looks as though the offensive plan for 2012 was supposed to go something like this: Weeden's maturity and big arm+Richardson will equal a pounding, play-action offense immediately. Maybe I didn't get the memo but that's the appearance from here. Worst case scenario? Opponents will load up the box and blitz Weeden while he flings deep fades to receivers not named Justin Blackmon.

    Then again who knows? I gave my "Magic 8-Ball" to your cousin's husband (my son in law.) Any chance you can score tickets to the 10/14 Bengals game? Take care.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey UC -

    You didn't miss much I promise. The WR's were always going to be a work in progress, although the passing game was just horrible all the way around. Everyone around here is really high on Josh Gordan, who they drafted in the Supplemental, but he didn't play at Utah last year and is going to take some time to develop. By all accounts he has the size and athleticism to be a #1, it's just up to him and the Browns to get him to that point.

    Weeden was bad, there's no way around it. He definitely operates better from a much cleaner pocket, that was a knock on him coming out, but he has the arm and I thought he had pretty good intermediate accuracy at Ok State. The line should get better as the gel and Richardson should be the focal point of the offense, but Weeden is going to have to complete some passes downfield to keep safeties out of the box. The coaches could help him by mixing up the offense a little, and the receivers can help by not dropping the ball. But yes the worst case scenario is that Weeden is as awful as he was last week, and in that case they'll be drafting his replacement with the first pick next April, IMO.

    What's your magic 8-ball?

    ReplyDelete